Not All NDIS Homes Are Equal: What to Look For in SIL

The brochure says “person-centred”. The website shows smiling faces, a garden and a home-cooked meal. But too often, families find something different once their loved one moves in: rotating staff, rigid rosters, little choice and care built around the provider, not the person.
Supported Independent Living (SIL) is meant to help people live the life they choose. When a home falls short, the cost isn’t just money. It’s a person’s wellbeing, safety and right to really live.
Here’s what the evidence says, what to watch for, and how the People First Nursing (PFN) model compares.

What the evidence says

This isn’t just our opinion. Three major reviews have reached similar conclusions.

The NDIS Review (2023) found that “many people still live in large or small group homes where they can’t choose their housemates or their service providers” (NDIS Review).

The Disability Royal Commission (2023) said “group homes can limit a person’s choices and can expose them to harm” (Disability Royal Commission). At its group homes hearing, it heard that “routines were organised for the convenience of staff and management” (Public Hearing 3).

The NDIS Quality and Safeguards Commission looked at about 7,000 incidents and complaints across seven large SIL providers. It found residents’ “experience is too often characterised by limited choice” (NDIS Commission).
The system is responding. Since 1 July 2026, many SIL providers must be registered with the NDIS Commission (NDIS Commission). In December 2025, the Federal Court ordered a record $2.5 million penalty against a provider that failed to keep residents of a SIL home safe (NDIS Commission).

Warning signs to watch for

Most support workers care deeply. But when the model is wrong, good people get stuck in bad systems. Watch for:

How the PFN model compares

We built our model to fix exactly these problems.
The PFN model Typical group home PFN
Feel of the home Service facility A real family home
Team Rotating staff in uniforms A consistent team, no uniforms, part of the household
Flexible daily routine Set by the roster Set by the person's lifelong habits and wishes
Choice and risk Risk-averse, "no" by default Risk tolerant: dignity of risk, a human right to really live
Pets and children Often not allowed Welcome
Changed behaviours
(Find root cause first)
Often managed with medication or restrictions Root cause found first: pain, unmet needs, clinical indicators
Clinical oversight Limited or none Nurse-led, with Directors who have 25+ years in gerontology and dementia
Families welcomed Kept at arm's length Partners in care, with direct access to RNs
Funding options NDIS only NDIS, private and Support at Home, combined where rules allow

Questions to ask any provider

Before you choose a home, ask:
A good provider will welcome these questions and answer them clearly.
Expect more
Your loved one deserves a home, not a facility. Choice, not a roster. A team that knows them, not a revolving door.
If the home you’re in isn’t delivering what it promised, talk to us. Call 1800 258 007, email info@peoplefirstnursing.com, or visit peoplefirstnursing.com.

Share Post :

Nicole Smith

Nicole Smith is a Registered Nurse, gerontologist, global human rights advocate and public speaker with 20 years’ experience advancing relationship-centered care. She is the co-founder and Principal of People First Nursing, delivering trusted consulting, hands-on clinical guidance, real life solutions and advocacy that priorities human rights, dignity, and lived experience.