The NDIS Review (2023) found that “many people still live in large or small group homes where they can’t choose their housemates or their service providers” (NDIS Review).
The Disability Royal Commission (2023) said “group homes can limit a person’s choices and can expose them to harm” (Disability Royal Commission). At its group homes hearing, it heard that “routines were organised for the convenience of staff and management” (Public Hearing 3).
| The PFN model | Typical group home | PFN |
|---|---|---|
| Feel of the home | Service facility | A real family home |
| Team | Rotating staff in uniforms | A consistent team, no uniforms, part of the household |
| Flexible daily routine | Set by the roster | Set by the person's lifelong habits and wishes |
| Choice and risk | Risk-averse, "no" by default | Risk tolerant: dignity of risk, a human right to really live |
| Pets and children | Often not allowed | Welcome |
| Changed behaviours (Find root cause first) |
Often managed with medication or restrictions | Root cause found first: pain, unmet needs, clinical indicators |
| Clinical oversight | Limited or none | Nurse-led, with Directors who have 25+ years in gerontology and dementia |
| Families welcomed | Kept at arm's length | Partners in care, with direct access to RNs |
| Funding options | NDIS only | NDIS, private and Support at Home, combined where rules allow |
Nicole Smith is a Registered Nurse, gerontologist, global human rights advocate and public speaker with 20 years’ experience advancing relationship-centered care. She is the co-founder and Principal of People First Nursing, delivering trusted consulting, hands-on clinical guidance, real life solutions and advocacy that priorities human rights, dignity, and lived experience.